Choosing the right materials for home improvements or construction projects is crucial. Among the many options available, Hardie-Backer cement board, Schluter waterproof membrane, and foam board stand out. Each of these materials has its own strengths and weaknesses, which can significantly influence the success of your project. This post provides a detailed comparison of these three materials, helping you make the best choice for your next renovation or building endeavor.
Understanding the Contenders
Before we compare, let’s outline what each of these materials is and how they are typically used.
Hardie-Backer Cement Board
Hardie-Backer is a cement board made from a blend of cement and cellulose fibers. It is specifically designed as a substrate for tile installations and is highly resistant to moisture. This makes it ideal for areas like bathrooms, kitchens, and laundry rooms.
Advantages:
Exceptional durability: Hardie-Backer can last for decades under tiles without deteriorating.
Mold and mildew resistant: Studies show it significantly reduces the growth of mold by up to 90%.
Strong foundation: It provides excellent support for heavy tiles and can withstand high foot traffic.
Cement is an organic material, which naturally guards against mold growth.
Cement is one of the oldest, most used and trusted construction substrates in the construction industry... has been the only foundation for public swimming pools since inception of pools.
Disadvantages:
Heavier than alternatives: Each sheet weighs about 1.5 to 2 times more than foam board, making installation more labor-intensive.
Requires additional waterproofing in wet areas: Depending on the project, you'll need to apply a waterproof sealant for optimal protection.
Schluter Waterproof Membrane
Schluter membranes are popular waterproofing solutions designed to create a watertight barrier. They are suitable for showers, wet rooms, and outdoor installations, eliminating moisture damage to underlying structures...Have been around for 40+ years and is considered the pinnacle of waterproofing applications for indoor showers. It is most ironclad waterproofing system when paired with cement board underlayment as the foundation.
Advantages:
Highly effective at preventing water infiltration: Schluter boasts a 100% success rate in preventing water damage when installed correctly.
Lightweight and easy to install: A single installer can typically handle the sheets without additional help.
Flexible application: Can be used on various surfaces, including wood, concrete, and tile.
Best application for custom sized showers and especially zero entrance showers where there is no margin for error
Disadvantages:
More expensive than cement boards: Costs can be 30% to 50% higher than Hardie-Backer.
Requires careful installation: Proper sealing is essential; an error in installation can lead to failures.
Takes several days longer to install; not feasible if you are in a hurry to complete your shower
Foam Board
Foam board is a lightweight, rigid insulation material often made from extruded polystyrene. Along with insulation benefits, it offers moisture resistance, making it a popular choice for specific applications, especially in below-grade or moisture-prone areas.
Advantages:
Exceptionally lightweight: At about 1/3 the weight of Hardie-Backer, foam board is easier to handle and install.
Insulating benefits: Foam boards can reduce energy costs by improving thermal resistance, potentially saving up to 15% on heating bills.
Cutting versatility: Simple to cut to size, making it accessible for DIY projects.
Disadvantages:
Lower strength compared to cement boards: Foam can compress under heavy loads, which may not be suitable for all applications.
Vulnerable to sharp objects: It can be easily damaged if not handled with care.
Relatively new in the industry; not long enough to determine the longevity and validate mold inhibiting factors.
Seams are joined with sealant caulking only, no overlap of materials or bands used, leaving margin for error and potential water-leaks if performed incorrectly.
Important Factors for Consideration
When selecting the right material, consider the following key factors: moisture resistance, durability, ease of installation, cost, and insulation properties.
Moisture Resistance
In moisture-prone areas like bathrooms and kitchens, moisture resistance is critical. Hardie-Backer and Schluter membranes excel in this aspect. While Hardie-Backer needs additional waterproofing, Schluter provides an effective solution for water protection over top of the cement board and is considered to be the gold standard waterproofing application
Foam board has moisture resistance properties but may not endure prolonged exposure to water as effectively as the other two options. For the highest protection in moist environments, consider combining Hardie-Backer with a Schluter waterproof membrane.
Durability
Durability matters, especially in high-traffic areas. Hardie-Backer is well-known for its strong construction and resistance to wear. For example, it can withstand heavy foot traffic, making it perfect for living spaces and kitchens.
Foam boards are easier to handle but may not stand up well under heavy loads. If you need lasting durability, especially for tile installations, Hardie-Backer is a solid choice.
Ease of Installation
Foam board leads in terms of ease of installation. Its lightweight nature allows for straightforward handling, and cuts can be made quickly and with minimal effort.
Hardie-Backer installation can be more labor-intensive due to its weight, often requiring additional tools or helpers for larger sheets. Schluter membranes are moderately complex to install, mainly due to the need for precise sealing.
Cost
Cost can heavily influence your choice of materials. Foam board is usually the most affordable option, making it attractive for budget-conscious projects. Hardie-Backer offers a balance of price and durability, while Schluter membranes tend to be on the higher end due to their sophisticated technology.
For example, a 3-foot x 5-foot sheet of foam board typically costs between $10 to $15, while a similar size of Hardie-Backer might cost around $15 to $25. Schluter membranes can range from $30 to $50 for comparable sizes.
Insulation Properties
Foam board excels in insulation, providing a thermal layer that can lower energy costs in homes. In contrast, Hardie-Backer and Schluter membranes do not provide insulation benefits; their main focus is on support and moisture prevention. If insulation is a key requirement, foam board is the way to go.
Popular Applications
Knowing where each material shines can guide your decision-making. Here's a breakdown of common applications for each contender.
Hardie-Backer Cement Board
Hardie-Backer is widely used in kitchens, bathrooms, and living areas for tile installations. It pairs well with ceramic and stone tiles, especially in wet zones, although additional waterproofing is often necessary.
Schluter Waterproof Membrane
Ideal for wet installations, Schluter membranes are perfect for showers, steam rooms, and areas where water contact is frequent. Their flexibility allows for use on walls and floors, ensuring comprehensive waterproofing.
Foam Board
Foam boards find their niche in basements, exterior walls, and under tiles where insulation and moisture resistance are important. They serve as a substrate for tiles, especially in areas prone to moisture.
Final Considerations: Choosing the Right Material
Selecting between Hardie-Backer cement board, Schluter waterproof membrane, and foam board ultimately hinges on your project's specific needs. Each material shines in different areas, emphasizing the need to consider moisture levels, durability, insulation needs, installation ease, and budget constraints.
If high moisture is a concern and durability is paramount, a combination of Hardie-Backer and Schluter is your best option. This pairing safeguards against moisture while providing a strong foundation for your tile work that will last for decades to come.
If you’re focused on a lightweight and easy-to-handle solution that provides insulation, foam board stands out as a cost-effective choice.
Whichever material you select, following manufacturer recommendations will ensure optimal performance and longevity of your installation. Happy building!
Comments